Yep, the real issue isn’t the fact that trans people are being excluded, the thing we need to talk about is how a trans person didn’t talk about their exclusion in a way you were comfortable with.
I’ve been on Lemmy long enough to realize that most on Lemmy don’t want to have nuance, or useful conversation. People here LIKE being mad.
There is a world wide growing movement against trans people. We have had our drivers licenses and passports taken away, we’ve been excluded from sports, we’ve had our protections against violent and sexual crime weakened and removed, we’ve had whole governments campaign on their desire to attack us.
I personally live in a country that has escaped the worst of it, but even so, do you know that I legally can’t enter the US? Not that I’d want to, but it would literally be impossible for me to provide ID that matches their expectations. And if I was let in anyway because some random person didn’t realise I was trans, I would face imprisonment if they identified that I’m trans.
I personally live in a country that has escaped the worst of it, but even so, do you know that I legally can’t enter the US? Not that I’d want to, but it would literally be impossible for me to provide ID that matches their expectations.
The US doesn’t ban trans people or gay people from entering. So what’s the actual reason that would you be banned from entering US?
Fuck nuance.
Which proves my point I was making. You don’t want nuance. I don’t care the reasons, my point stands: you don’t care about nuance.
They ban people whose identity documents don’t match their assigned sex at birth (ie, me). All of my documents list me as female. Birth certificate, passport, ID card etc.
So if I declare that I’m trans, they deny me a visa, because my documents don’t match their transphobic guidelines. And if I don’t declare that I’m trans, and they let me in, then they can hit me for entering the country with “fraudulent” documentation if they later identity me as transgender.
The irony being here, you aren’t interested in nuance either. You’ve got your line in the sand, and it doesn’t matter how much exclusion, harm or bigotry you see, how explicitly exclusion from sports is shown to be a wedge issue to normalise exclusion of trans people from other levels of society, your opinion won’t change.
Yep, the real issue isn’t the fact that trans people are being excluded, the thing we need to talk about is how a trans person didn’t talk about their exclusion in a way you were comfortable with.
There is a world wide growing movement against trans people. We have had our drivers licenses and passports taken away, we’ve been excluded from sports, we’ve had our protections against violent and sexual crime weakened and removed, we’ve had whole governments campaign on their desire to attack us.
I personally live in a country that has escaped the worst of it, but even so, do you know that I legally can’t enter the US? Not that I’d want to, but it would literally be impossible for me to provide ID that matches their expectations. And if I was let in anyway because some random person didn’t realise I was trans, I would face imprisonment if they identified that I’m trans.
Fuck nuance.
The US doesn’t ban trans people or gay people from entering. So what’s the actual reason that would you be banned from entering US?
Which proves my point I was making. You don’t want nuance. I don’t care the reasons, my point stands: you don’t care about nuance.
They ban people whose identity documents don’t match their assigned sex at birth (ie, me). All of my documents list me as female. Birth certificate, passport, ID card etc.
So if I declare that I’m trans, they deny me a visa, because my documents don’t match their transphobic guidelines. And if I don’t declare that I’m trans, and they let me in, then they can hit me for entering the country with “fraudulent” documentation if they later identity me as transgender.
Here’s a breakdown of how it works https://www.huschblackwell.com/newsandinsights/new-visa-rules-target-transgender-individuals-considerations-for-employers-and-educational-institutions
The irony being here, you aren’t interested in nuance either. You’ve got your line in the sand, and it doesn’t matter how much exclusion, harm or bigotry you see, how explicitly exclusion from sports is shown to be a wedge issue to normalise exclusion of trans people from other levels of society, your opinion won’t change.